Hoover’s theory that the murders in Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky and West Virginia were committed by the UNSUB in St. Louis was based purely on conjecture, but that doesn’t make it any less plausible or probable. Despite his years of training and following procedure, he still trusted his instincts, which no amount of book work can replace.
Now it was my turn for a little conjecture.
“This is going to sound crazy, but I think there might be a possible connection between the guy you’re hunting and the one in Minnesota.” I said to Hoover, who remained impassive. “Go on.” He implored. “The killer in St. Louis headed out-of-town and continued killing in the successive states, just like the killer in Minnesota. He’s changed his method of killing from time to time, so has the one in Minnesota. One kills men, the other kills women, but there patterns are similar, which means they may know each other or be corresponding.” I could see that Hoover was considering my theory, but I could also feel his suddenly piercing eyes sizing me up. “You think the UNSUB in Minnesota might be one of your uncle’s chat buddies?” “Why not? Every other dingbat seems to be.” The profiler cracked a slight smile. “I’ll call the team in Virginia, and tell them to go through all of your uncle’s online friends again.” “It’s too late.” I said. “Maybe not, Brookings.” “You don’t know my uncle, sir. He was sloppy killer while free, but he’s become very cagey while in captivity.” Hoover arched his eyebrows and gave me a quizzical look. “You talk about him like he’s an animal.” “No, he’s not an animal, he’s a monster who uses others for his own amusement. It’s too bad that there isn’t a way to keep Doane out in society without him hurting anyone, because he wasn’t this cunning on the streets.” “Normally, I would have dismissed your theory and never thought about it again, but the crazier this gets, the more real it is, if that makes sense.” Hoover said.
It sounded logical to me.